How to use influence to boost email results

On By - Analytics, ROI, Strategy - Add Comment

Use principles of influence to increase your email marketing results by 288 percent.

Ask any Internet marketing expert what makes an email marketing campaign more likely to be successful, and you’re liable to hear a common refrain: valuable content. Content is king. Send relevant email to people who asked for it.

While all these answers are true, they’re incomplete. They don’t provide you with a more comprehensive view of email marketing from the perspective of getting your subscribers to do what you want them to do.

In 1999, Dr. Robert Cialdini postulated the 6 principles of influence and persuasion that can be leveraged to make influence and persuasion techniques more effective. Let’s take a look at these and how they might be able to improve the influence of your email marketing. The 6 weapons are:

  1. Reciprocity. People tend to return a favor and honor social debts.
  2. Consistency. People will tend to honor a commitment and be consistent with previous behaviors.
  3. Social proof. People tend to follow the herd.
  4. Authority. People tend to obey authority figures.
  5. Likeness. People tend to be influenced by those they are like and those they like.
  6. Scarcity. People tend to act faster under the perception of scarcity.


How would each of these principles be used in email marketing?

Reciprocity. Offer your subscribers something of value. This may be content, or it may be a material good or service. Whatever it is, Cialdini’s version of reciprocity does not necessarily enforce a quid pro quo. Give, and then ask after you’ve gained influence. Of all the techniques, internet marketers tend to make use of this the most.

Consistency. People tend to behave consistently, aligned with previous behaviors. Cialdini cites the example of going around the neighborhood with a petition for a cause and then going around again a week later soliciting donations for the cause. Donors nearly doubled with the use of the petition because people wished to be consistent with their previous signature of the petition. Think about how you can use behavioral consistencies – subscribing to an email, taking a poll or survey, etc. – to create a behavior and then use a followup campaign to elicit the response you seek.

Social proof. Tools like Forward to a Friend and Share With Your Network, combined with other social media outlets, can radically change your email marketing. Email is mentally considered a private communication between two parties (even when it’s clearly a newsletter), but having other people sharing it and talking about it provides very public social proof that your email marketing has value. Encourage and incentivize your subscribers to share as much as possible.

Authority. Presumably people subscribe to your email newsletters because you have some degree of knowledge and authority, enough credibility for people to want to read what you have to say. Provide people with the tools they need to become authorities in their own social circles and your email marketing will be unstoppable. For example, Peter Shankman’s Help a Reporter allowed PR and marketing professionals to have free access to journalism inquiries that they otherwise wouldn’t have gotten. Not only was Shankman an authority on PR, but he empowered each of his subscribers to become authorities in their respective companies, creating press and earned media opportunities seemingly out of thin air.

Likeness. How well do you know your audience? For good or ill, we are easily persuaded by people who are like us, or are people we like. Again, tools like Share With Your Network allow email marketers to reach prospects who are social friends – like people – of subscribers. More broadly, think about the imagery in your email marketing and whether it’s aligned to your audience. If your marketing data indicates that your audience is largely Hispanic, having content and imagery focused on Swedish personas will simply not resonate. If your email doesn’t come from a person or persona at your company, think about creating one (or several) aligned to your audience to create likeness.

Scarcity. Whatever you have to offer, there’s a way to make it scarce. It could be a time limited special offer, or a limited quantity. It could be your time and knowledge in a consulting capacity about a subject matter you have expertise in. Find a way to bring some scarcity to what you have to offer.

Let’s look at a case study and some results of using these principles. Marketing Over Coffee recently published a newsletter in which a contest for free passes to a marketing conference was the prize. The contest terms were simple: share the newsletter with your colleagues, and the five people who brought the most number of new eyeballs will win the contest.

How many principles are at work?

  1. Reciprocity: yes. In addition to the contest, the newsletter publishes a large collection of free resources.
  2. Consistency: yes. Subscribers to the newsletter have already acted on a previous behavior (subscribing).
  3. Social proof: unquestionably. The very nature of the contest demands social proof in abundance.
  4. Authority: maybe, though again the free reading list of marketing resources does give subscribers some additional tools to enhance their own expertise.
  5. Likeness: yes. Again, the contest is all about friends “selling” to friends.
  6. Scarcity: the contest brings scarcity to an otherwise abundant resource (marketing newsletter).

Now let’s check the results.

The previous edition of the newsletter, issue 4, had a clickthrough rate of 4.7% and a reach increase of 13.84 percent via sharing with your network. (reach increase is defined as the number of eyeballs outside of your subscriber base who read your newsletter)

The contest edition of the newsletter, issue 5, had a clickthrough rate of 4.8% as well, but a reach increase of 53.74 percent via sharing with your network, a 288 percent increase in reach from the previous edition.

Is Cialdini’s checklist the definitive answer to making your email marketing more powerful? No. Is it part of the answer? Absolutely. Try it out with your own email marketing, integrate his principles into what you’re doing, and see if you can create some similar results.

Christopher S. Penn

Share on LinkedIn8Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook2Share on Google+0

free ebook download

Click Here To Download

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *