How To Boost Email ROI With Autoresponse Campaigns

Last week’s stunning and game-changing updates to Google Analytics with multichannel funnels have raised an entirely new set of questions to most email marketers. Given that we now have a way to measure the impact of email beyond just pushing prospects over the line to an immediate sale, what new tactics, strategies, and ideas should we be examining?

Let’s start with the email marketing funnel. For a quick refresher:

WhatCounts Email Funnel

Prior to multichannel funnels, most of our email marketing efforts were focused on one of two areas: sending email to leads to compel them to grow into customers, and monthly newsletter because we felt that we had to. With multichannel funnels, we can now more accurately assess our email marketing efforts at every stage of the funnel.

Given this, what can we be doing to increase email’s effectiveness in a measurable fashion? The answer lies in a specific email methodology known as autoresponse campaigns, in which you send timed or triggered email messages to highly targeted lists.

Acquire

Strategy: The most obvious thing you can and should be doing is encouraging sharing, especially social sharing, of your email content. This necessitates having content worth sharing (people rarely share the mediocre, only the wonderfully good and horrifically bad) as well as an encouragement to share.

Tactics: Have great content. If you don’t have great content, then become known as a curator for great content by subscribing to as many reputable blogs in your industry and then putting together lists of curated content in your email. From there, use behavioral autoresponse campaigns for anyone who does share your content to encourage them and incentivize them to share even more.

Convert

Strategy: The path to converting a prospect into a lead, into someone interested in doing business with you, is through value. Provide them as much value as you can practically and reasonably create. Your goal at the convert stage is to become the authority and the only reasonable choice for your prospects to buy from, effectively warming them up for a sale.

Tactics: Use an automated response campaign to send prospects a series of tips, white papers, and other content to maintain presence of mind. For example, if you were a large food retailer, sending original recipes to your subscribers would provide them additional reasons to consider shopping at your store. Food manufacturers have put together free recipe books for years featuring recipes that require the use of the manufacturer’s products.

Grow

Strategy: To grow someone into a customer, you need to accurately understand their budget, need, timeframe, and if you’re selling something that requires participation of more than an individual, authority. Sometimes these criteria happen in the blink of an eye, like the purchase of a pack of gum at checkout. The need is immediate, the budget is whatever spare change is in your pocket, the timeframe is immediate, and the authority is just you. Sometimes these criteria happen over the period of years as companies consider multibillion dollar contracts.

Tactics: Growing a lead into a customer requires constant reinforcement of a structure that marketer Dan Kennedy promotes: P/A/GS/SS. With your email marketing, in your copy and in your campaigns, remind or elicit the problem that your prospective customers have. Incite agitation about the problem, about the opportunity costs or unrealized benefits. Suggest the general solution that addresses the problem, then conclude with your specific solution. Perform this marketing structure with autoresponse campaigns that are triggered off of behaviors from previous emails; for example, if someone subscribes and downloads all of your white papers and attends your webinars, they are indicating through their behavior that they might be ready for a more substantial conversation and would be ideal candidates for a targeted autoresponse campaign.

Retain

Strategy: Once someone’s become a customer, use value-enhancing email to retain them and turn them into evangelists.

Tactics: Building loyalty through autoresponse campaigns is simple (if not easy). From the moment of purchase, send a series of timed autoresponse campaigns providing tips for getting the most out of a purchase. Offer suggestions, ideas, and recipe-like content (“5 new ways to use your email marketing platform”) so that customers continue to increase the amount of value they get from you. Offer frequent encouragement to share post-conversion content as well, as that can then lead to new audience and prospects to reach.

As you set up each autoresponse campaign, make sure that you track them using distinct labels such as [WC Guests] or [WC Influencers] in the subjects. Not only will these labels help customers identify your mail from everything else in their inboxes, it will also help you carefully track what’s working in your multichannel funnels. If you see, for example, [WC Customers] emails showing up in your early acquisition/first touch reports, you know that your evangelists are sharing your post-conversion messages as intended. If you see surprises like [WC Guests] showing up in lead conversion, you know you’ve got some additional research to do for new marketing opportunities.

As we stated last week, multichannel funnels are nothing new conceptually, but their broad availability to marketers at any company and budget size is what’s the game changer. Start using effective autoresponse campaigns to create a consistent, valuable flow of emails to reinforce assisted conversions all along your funnel, and your email ROI will skyrocket as a result.

Christopher S. Penn
Director of Strategy, WhatCounts


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page:


Multi-Channel Funnels Show the Power of Email+Social

Google announced on August 24, 2011 that multi-channel funnel analytics (hereafter abbreviated MCF-GA) were available to all Google Analytics users. Today, we’re going to share with you how to understand MCF-GA and demonstrate the power of email marketing to help you understand what counts in your digital marketing programs.

Before we begin, MCF-GA requires that you have configured goals and goal values in your Google Analytics settings (see this page in Google’s help site). If you haven’t done this yet, it’s imperative that you do so. Don’t rush through this part; setting up reliable goals and goal values is essential to making MCF-GA work properly.

MCF-GA also requires you to be using the latest version of Google Analytics. Be sure to check in the upper right hand corner for the newest version and that you’re using it.

Assisted Conversions - Google Analytics
click for a larger version

Once you’ve logged in, start by generically reviewing your funnels. Click on the assisted conversions to see a nice breakout of your general marketing channels and how they are performing. Pay attention to the box at the right, highlighted in pink. This conversion ratio shows you how instrumental a channel is in either achieving the goal itself or leading your customers to the completion of your goals. The larger the number, the higher up in your overall marketing funnel a channel is. The lower the number, the closer a channel is to actually completing the sale.

In the example above, we see that email is responsible for $928 of assisted conversions and $1,160 last interaction conversions. Put another way, email helped close an additional $928 of sales in addition to pushing $1,160 of business over the finish line. If you had not been leveraging email marketing as a marketing method, you would have not only missed out on $1,160 of direct business, but potentially lost up to $928 in deals from other sources that email helped along.

The implications of this are incredible and profound. By demonstrating email’s role in your marketing channel above and beyond prompting customers to buy, you can get a bigger picture view of its influence in your marketing program and how it’s helping other channels close business as well.

Let’s dive further down the rabbit hole. Instead of a basic channel grouping, let’s look at individual campaigns. Here’s an example of looking at emails by subject line and their influence on conversions:

Assisted Conversions - Google Analytics
click for a larger version

What we see here are the results of a set of newsletters that went out. Note that only one of the newsletters prompted a direct sale. In the old, pre-MCF-GA world, we might have made the mistake of saying that our weekly newsletter had a tiny quantifiable benefit to our business, only 1 conversion. In the new MCF-GA world, we see that in fact, our newsletters had 1 conversion and 11 assists. Instead of assigning email marketing a value of $116 in sales, we can make the bold statement that it had $116 in direct sales and influenced an additional $1,276 in other sales. Suddenly, you understand that the  newsletter is a lot more valuable!

Now as an email marketer, you can go back to your shareholders or executives and demonstrate a bigger picture of the value you bring to the table and to driving your business forward.

By the way, you can use this to demonstrate the power of any channel, not just email marketing:

Assisted Conversions - Google Analytics
click for a larger version

Your work in social media suddenly shows a much greater return on investment than last touch attribution has given it previously. In the example above, our work on Twitter has driven no direct conversions itself, but assisted with $853 in overall conversion value. If you were hastily considering curtailing your social media efforts before MCF-GA, you may want to reconsider until you have more detailed data that shows you a bigger picture of the impact of social media on your marketing efforts.

Here’s the official announcement and video:

MCF-GA is a critical new tool in your marketing arsenal. With it, you’ll gain a much broader understanding of what works and how the pieces fit together. You’ll understand and be able to justify investments in channels like email and social because you’ll see the results all along your sales and marketing funnel, not just at the bottom.

In short, by implementing MCF-GA in combination with your enterprise email marketing efforts, you’ll truly know… what counts.

Christopher S. Penn
Director of Strategy, WhatCounts


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page:


How to use influence to boost email results

Use principles of influence to increase your email marketing reach by 288%

Ask any Internet marketing expert what makes an email marketing campaign more likely to be successful, and you’re liable to hear a common refrain: valuable content. Content is king. Send relevant email to people who asked for it.

While all these answers are true, they’re incomplete. They don’t provide you with a more comprehensive view of email marketing from the perspective of getting your subscribers to do what you want them to do.

In 1999, Dr. Robert Cialdini postulated the 6 principles of influence and persuasion that can be leveraged to make influence and persuasion techniques more effective. Let’s take a look at these and how they might be able to improve the influence of your email marketing. The 6 weapons are:

  1. Reciprocity. People tend to return a favor and honor social debts.
  2. Consistency. People will tend to honor a commitment and be consistent with previous behaviors.
  3. Social proof. People tend to follow the herd.
  4. Authority. People tend to obey authority figures.
  5. Likeness. People tend to be influenced by those they are like and those they like.
  6. Scarcity. People tend to act faster under the perception of scarcity.

eduweb.key

How would each of these principles be used in email marketing?

Reciprocity. Offer your subscribers something of value. This may be content, or it may be a material good or service. Whatever it is, Cialdini’s version of reciprocity does not necessarily enforce a quid pro quo. Give, and then ask after you’ve gained influence. Of all the techniques, internet marketers tend to make use of this the most, such as with things like the WhatCounts Lifecycle Email Marketing White Paper.

Consistency. People tend to behave consistently, aligned with previous behaviors. Cialdini cites the example of going around the neighborhood with a petition for a cause and then going around again a week later soliciting donations for the cause. Donors nearly doubled with the use of the petition because people wished to be consistent with their previous signature of the petition. Think about how you can use behavioral consistencies – subscribing to an email, taking a poll or survey, etc. – to create a behavior and then use a followup campaign to elicit the response you seek.

Social proof. Tools like Forward to a Friend and Share With Your Network, combined with other social media outlets, can radically change your email marketing. Email is mentally considered a private communication between two parties (even when it’s clearly a newsletter), but having other people sharing it and talking about it provides very public social proof that your email marketing has value. Encourage and incentivize your subscribers to share as much as possible.

Authority. Presumably people subscribe to your email newsletters because you have some degree of knowledge and authority, enough credibility for people to want to read what you have to say. Provide people with the tools they need to become authorities in their own social circles and your email marketing will be unstoppable. For example, Peter Shankman’s Help a Reporter allowed PR and marketing professionals to have free access to journalism inquiries that they otherwise wouldn’t have gotten. Not only was Shankman an authority on PR, but he empowered each of his subscribers to become authorities in their respective companies, creating press and earned media opportunities seemingly out of thin air.

Likeness. How well do you know your audience? For good or ill, we are easily persuaded by people who are like us, or are people we like. Again, tools like Share With Your Network allow email marketers to reach prospects who are social friends – like people – of subscribers. More broadly, think about the imagery in your email marketing and whether it’s aligned to your audience. If your marketing data indicates that your audience is largely Hispanic, having content and imagery focused on Swedish personas will simply not resonate. If your email doesn’t come from a person or persona at your company, think about creating one (or several) aligned to your audience to create likeness.

Scarcity. Whatever you have to offer, there’s a way to make it scarce. It could be a time limited special offer, or a limited quantity. It could be your time and knowledge in a consulting capacity about a subject matter you have expertise in. Find a way to bring some scarcity to what you have to offer.

Let’s look at a case study and some results of using these principles. Marketing Over Coffee recently published a newsletter in which a contest for free passes to a marketing conference was the prize. The contest terms were simple: share the newsletter with your colleagues, and the five people who brought the most number of new eyeballs will win the contest.

How many principles are at work?

  1. Reciprocity: yes. In addition to the contest, the newsletter publishes a large collection of free resources.
  2. Consistency: yes. Subscribers to the newsletter have already acted on a previous behavior (subscribing).
  3. Social proof: unquestionably. The very nature of the contest demands social proof in abundance.
  4. Authority: maybe, though again the free reading list of marketing resources does give subscribers some additional tools to enhance their own expertise.
  5. Likeness: yes. Again, the contest is all about friends “selling” to friends.
  6. Scarcity: the contest brings scarcity to an otherwise abundant resource (marketing newsletter).

Now let’s check the results.

The previous edition of the newsletter, issue 4, had a clickthrough rate of 4.7% and a reach increase of 13.84% via sharing with your network. (reach increase is defined as the number of eyeballs outside of your subscriber base who read your newsletter)

The contest edition of the newsletter, issue 5, had a clickthrough rate of 4.8% as well, but a reach increase of 53.74% via sharing with your network, a 288% increase in reach from the previous edition.

Is Cialdini’s checklist the definitive answer to making your email marketing more powerful? No. Is it part of the answer? Absolutely. Try it out with your own email marketing, integrate his principles into what you’re doing, and see if you can create some similar results.

Christopher S. Penn
Director of Strategy
WhatCounts

Keep Branding Consistent

Stay consistent when it comes to branding. Keep this in mind when it comes to your from name, from address, subject line, overall email design and graphics, and voice (among other possible elements of your email). Not only will your email be recognized in a crowded inbox, recipients also prefer and appreciate a familiar look so they know where each element of an email can be found.

WhatCounts Email Summit keynote speaker announced

We are very excited to announce that Shar VanBoskirk of Forrester Research will be giving the keynote address at the 2011 WhatCounts Email Summit on October 5th. Shar will speak about the current state of email marketing, why most emailers fail to create good lifecycle messaging and what best practices you can employ to develop successful lifecycle programs.

We’ve also made updates to the agenda and have added several new speakers to the website.

New speakers include:

  • Shar VanBoskirk, Vice President, Principal Analyst, Forrester Research
  • Ian Medlock, Email Marketing Manager, Virgin America
  • Jeanne Jones, Email Marketing Manager, Alaska Airlines
  • Amy Norton, Director, Online Marketing at Costco Wholesale
  • Peter Westerman, SVP Audience Marketing, Ziff Davis Enterprise
  • Phil Davis, GM of Marketing Services, Rapleaf

If you haven’t yet registered, use discount code email11 by August 25th to save 25% off your ticket.

Register for WhatCounts Email Summit in Las Vegas, NV  on Eventbrite

We hope to see you in Vegas!

Email Frequency: How Often Is Too Often?

Events Calendar (Flickr: Yandle)What is the best email frequency? How often is too often?

That is one of those questions that is often asked in the world of email marketing. Frequency. Timing. Do I send once per quarter? What about monthly? Or weekly? Is a daily email too much? What about several times per day?

Ready for the answer? The short answer is one that you are not going to love. You already know what it is, but I’ll say it anyway. It depends.

So much of what works in email marketing relies on testing. Test different frequencies, ask your subscribers, and then test again. However, there are 6 general guidelines for frequency that may prove to be useful starting points.

  1. You should send quarterly if… you really don’t have much to say or don’t have the time/resources available to say it. One thing to keep in mind is if you send quarterly, your chances of having deliverabilty issues increase. Why? First off, folks are less likely to remember who you are and that they subscribed (delete/spam). Also, the email address could no longer be valid resulting in hard bounces and possible spam traps.
  2. You should send monthly if… you have a newsletter. I believe that this is the minimum frequency.  The goal with a monthly email is often to inform. At WhatCounts, we send out monthly newsletters (subscribe here!).  Our newsletters is meant to keep our subscribers up-to-date on the latest happenings at WhatCounts. We include recent blog posts, upcoming events, and other tidbits of email knowledge. However, if your goal is to sell a product or service (think: conversions), monthly is too infrequent.
  3. You should send bi-monthly (2x per month) if… you want to hit the sweet spot for most subscribers. It’s a nice balance between monthly and weekly. Most organizations and/or individuals can crank out solid content every few weeks. It’s doable. It’s repeatable. That being said, this is where some pause and say, “Do we have enough to say every other week?” If you are worried about not having enough content every other week, think about ways to pull existing content (blog posts, press releases, website copy) and repurpose.
  4. You should send weekly if… you are selling a product or service. This would be the minimum. If you have a sale or an updated service offering or new product, let your subscribers know about it every week. Some choose to send on the same day and time every week. We would recommend testing – always. Remember also that you don’t have to pump out a ton of copy in each email. It can be simple – short and to the point as our client and friend Jason Keath does with The Social Fresh 7. Feature a handful of products. Promote a few blog posts.
  5. You should send daily if… you are Daily Candy! That was an easy one. Daily emails can work. The key on these are that you must be able to produce quality actionable, valuable, relevant, and timely content every single day. Most email marketers are unable to keep up with this cadence. And that’s okay.  If you can – and have the resources to pull it off – go for it. The only caution on a daily email is be sure to track your metrics carefully and often. If you see a drop in opens, clicks, or conversions – consider pulling back a bit. If you see complaints and unsubscribes increase – test whether every other day changes those numbers.
  6. You should send more than once per day if… you are HARO! If you’ve ever subscribed to Help a Reporter Out (Peter Shankman), you’ll see why more than once per day works. I would not recommend this frequency unless you have super-time sensitive emails like HARO does. This is where automation comes into play, unless you have a large team dedicated full-time to content production and sending emails.

Note: This list does not include automated/triggered emails that can be sent multiple times per day based on a user action or time-based event.

So there you have it. The definitive answer on how often to send email marketing campaigns. Still have questions about email frequency?  Feel free to contact us today and we’ll be happy to advise you on your specific needs.

Photo Credit – Flickr (CC): yandle

=======================

Originally posted by DJ Waldow
Revised and Updated by Michelle Wolverton for WhatCounts.com


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page:


Video in Email How-To and Best Practices

In our recent “Seamless Video Email: BEST PRACTICES FOR DRAMATICALLY INCREASING RESPONSE RATES & SUCCESS” white paper, we outlined several best practices for dramatically increasing response rates and success for your email program using video. Forrester has reported that video in email can increase click through rates by as much as 2-3x. So, it’s clear that email engagement may be easily improved with the addition of video. Not only that, but using the WhatCounts click-to-play solution, you can also track that engagement even further by analyzing viewing behavior and tracking key metrics.  On top of that, triggered messages can also be set up to fire based on the user’s engagement with the video.

But, you haven’t tried it and don’t know where to get started.  Read through our best practice white paper and then use our simple guide below to help you create even more compelling messages via WhatCounts!

To create a template with a video:

  • Go to Content > View Templates to display the Templates page.
  • Click Add, or select a template to edit and display the Create / Edit Template page.
  • If you’re creating a new template, enter a Name and Subject.
  • Click the HTML tab to enter the content for your email message.  The video will not display in the plain text version.
  • Click Add Video. The Dynamic Video Library tab will display within the page.
  • Click to select a video within the list. The image that will appear in your message and its associated properties will display to the right.

  • Click Add to Template. The Dynamic Template Videos tab will display.
  • Click to select the video within the list, and then click Configure Tag.  Make any changes to the properties described below (Configuring the Video Tag) and then click Save and Copy. The Video Tag will be copied to your clipboard.

  • Click Close and then paste the tag in the desired location within the HTML content of your message. Either right click in the Body field and select Paste from the menu, or press the CTRL+V keys on the keyboard.

  • Click Create or Save to save the template.
  • To preview the message, click on Update and then choose Preview.  If you’d like to change the image that displays in your email, just follow the directions in “Configuring the Video Tag” below. The link you will have to update is the Image URL.


  • Make sure to test your campaign to confirm that everything is working properly!

Configuring the Video Tag

While any video can be added to any template, each template requires additional configuration of the video properties. These properties are only used for the specific template in which the properties are configured.

To configure the Video Tag for a template:

  1. In the template you are editing, click Add Video. The Dynamic Video Library tab will display within the page.
  2. Click the Template Videos tab. All videos that have been selected from the Video Library to include in the template will display.
  3. Click to select one video within the list, and then click Configure Tag. The video properties will display, allowing you to configure the following:
    • Image URL: Location of the image to display in the template. When you upload a video, a screenshot is taken from the video and saved as a .jpg to display in the message sent to the subscriber. If you would like to use an alternate image, such as an animated .gif, you may enter the URL to the image.
    • Link URL: Page to open when a subscriber clicks on the video in the Display message.
    • Link Text: Text to display when a subscriber mouses over the video in the Display message.
    • Player Dimensions: Width and Height of the video player.
    • Auto-Play Video: Option to play the video as soon as the Display message page is viewed. Enabled by default.
    • Audio enabled on Start: Option to play the audio as soon as the video starts playing. Enabled by default.
  4. Make any changes to the properties, and then click Save and Copy. The Video Tag will be copied to your clipboard.

Want to learn more about video enhanced emails? Take a look at our short demo of how quick and easy it is to use video in your email.

If you are a WhatCounts customer who would like to use this feature, please reach out to your Technical Account Manager.

Agatha Niedzwiecki
Marketing Manager
WhatCounts

Reduce spam reports of your email marketing

What’s the worst button in the world, the one button as an email marketer you don’t ever want your customers to be pressing?

Gmail - Inbox (2) - cspenn@gmail.com

The moment any customer, any subscriber presses this button, it automatically begins to drastically affect your ability to deliver communications to all of your customers. Subscribers who press this button endanger your entire email marketing list. So how do you prevent this behavior? Make unsubscribing easy and obvious.

This is deeply counterintuitive to many marketers. It’s even offensive to some; having worked hard to build up their lists, they’ll ask why they should make it easy for people to diminish the results of their efforts.

Here’s the bottom line: someone who doesn’t want to receive email from you for any reason will take the easiest way out of getting email from you. If your unsubscribe option isn’t obvious, they’ll flag you as spam and put your entire list in jeopardy. Make it easy and obvious to opt-out, and people will press the “report spam” button less frequently.

Here’s an example from a mailing we did to a list of webinar registrants. At the very top of the mailing, we provided a very obvious, very explicit opt-out notice:

WhatCounts

There was absolutely no question where the unsubscribe link was. What were the results? (this is the part that shocks the doubting marketers)

  • Sent: 1,657
  • Opened: 21.8% (355)
  • Clicked: 7.8% (127)
  • Opted-out: 0.5% – EIGHT PEOPLE
  • Complaint/Flagged as Spam: ZERO

Fewer than 1% opted out of the email. No one reported it as spam.

Offering a way to unsubscribe from a list is the law. Making it easy means that while you will lose a little bit of your list, you are guaranteed to retain the people who want to receive email from you and preserve the quality of your reputation. If you continue to provide value in your email communications, you’ll be able to make unsubscribing easy without significantly reducing the size of your list, and you’ll keep your subscribers away from touching the worst button in the world.

Christopher S. Penn
Director of Strategy, WhatCounts


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page:


How Bulk Filters Affect Your Email Marketing

A few weeks ago I activated a Gmail Lab feature known as SmartLabels to keep my inbox a tad cleaner and easier to manage.  SmartLabels takes Priority Inbox to the next step by removing bulk emails such as newsletters, mailing lists, forums, and notifications from accounts like Twitter and Facebook.

It creates a set of filters and labels in your Gmail account and archives them from your inbox so you receive the email but don’t have to go through the process of archiving every single Twitter follower notification or such that you get.

I find that I read a lot of newsletters at the end of the week on Sunday to catch up rather than during the week when I’m primarily reading my RSS feeds. So why leave them in my inbox all week as clutter?

If you have a lot of avid Gmail fans in your subscriber lists, they have probably heard about or tried this feature for themselves. SmartLabels take a while to train which means that your newsletters are probably going to get stuck in the filter until subscribers fish them out.  Check your domains to see if this is an area of concern for you.

Bonus tip: If you are a WhatCounts customer using Publicaster, you can find out quickly how many of your subscribers are Gmail users by going to the List Manager tab, choose the list you want to review and scroll down until you see Top Domain Chart.  (Example below.)

How do you stand out in the crowd of newsletters?  How do you create something so valuable that people miss it when it’s gone?  In short, you send valuable messages to your subscribers.  Something worth sticking around for and filling up their inbox with.  A great example is Help A Reporter Out created by Peter Shankman. If you get emails asking why the afternoon version is late or if you have a 70% open rate, you’re doing it right.

You might consider encouraging users to add your email to their whitelist to ensure proper delivery.  This will make sure your email doesn’t go to spam.  Also consider reminding Gmail users to flag the email as not bulk or not notifications or adding it to Priority Inbox so it doesn’t get buried.

Take a moment to consider what other actions your subscribers could take that would make your email suddenly disappear from view and ask yourself if you are creating content that is remarkable enough that they would miss it if it were gone.  If there answer is no, roll up your sleeves, we have somework to do.


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page:


When is the best time to send email? (Part 1)

What’s one of the most frequently asked questions in email marketing? (and social media marketing, too)

When is the best time to send email?

Today we’re going to definitively answer this question for you and provide you with exactly when you need to send. The answer is: when your subscribers want it the most.

Probably not the revelation you were looking for, was it? The follow on question might be: when do my subscribers want it?

The answer is to follow this recipe.

First, assuming your list is large enough to be sent out over a 7 day period, pick a week to send out a mailing. Make sure there are no holidays or other anomalies that would significantly skew your results if possible.

Create a strong message that has a valuable call to action that subscribers are likely to want to act on, such as a free white paper or something requiring little or no commitment. Purchase as a call to action is fine as well, but it has to be something that can be tracked as an online conversion and something that’s going to be appealing. If your email service provider supports conversion tracking, make sure it is enabled. WhatCounts customers should enable Google Analytics in your realm and make sure that goals are set up to record the desired conversion behavior.

In your email service provider of choice, schedule a send to be metered and distributed on the hour for 168 hours, or 7 days, beginning at midnight on a Sunday. For WhatCounts users, divide your subscriber list by 168 and then input that number in the advanced deployment options, then schedule the send to begin at midnight on Sunday.

Deploy Campaign

Give your campaign about a week for results to finally settle down, then log into Google Analytics. Choose Custom Reporting and create a new custom report, then select Total Goal Completions, Source/Medium, Day, and Hour as your metrics and dimensions. It should look like this:

Edit Custom Report - Google Analytics

Set the time period in Google Analytics to be the week of your campaign and the week after, for a two week total period total. In the list of sources, look for your email service provider. WhatCounts customers will obviously click on WhatCounts/email.

Once the custom report loads, click on Day to sort, and you’ll have a neat list of how many conversions per day during the testing period you got, including the day of the week:

Custom Report - Google Analytics

Click on any given day of the week to see what times of day your campaign resonated most with subscribers:

Custom Report - Google Analytics

As you can see, this campaign clearly generated the most results at 9 AM Eastern Time, and on Thursdays. More people opened the email, read it, and then went on to the web site and clicked through to a conversion on Thursdays at 9 AM than at any other time during the day.

So let’s review the process:

  1. Set up a strong message with an offer likely to be acted on.
  2. Turn on Google Analytics and configure it to track goal conversions.
  3. Set up a campaign for a 168 hour send.
  4. Send evenly over a 7 day period so that you have even audience reception.
  5. Wait a week after the campaign ends.
  6. Create a custom report to analyze by time of day.
  7. Identify the time of day when conversions are highest.

Congratulations! You’ve successfully figured out exactly when to send email to maximize the conversions you’re looking for. This is absolutely vital to understand: you’re not checking when people open your message the most, you’re checking to see when they perform a valuable behavior for you the most. Your audience has told you through objective data exactly when they are most receptive to a valuable offer and are willing to act on it. Change your subsequent mailings as appropriate.

By the way, this method works for every other source in the list, too. If you want to see how Twitter, Facebook, or any other referring source is performing and when you should be tweeting, use this methodology. It will revolutionize how you make decisions about when to market on any given channel to maximize the one true metric you care about: business generated.

If you’re a WhatCounts customer and would like help setting this up, please contact your Account Manager and they’ll be glad to help you get rolling. If you’re using our Campaign Production Services and would like to develop this kind of testing campaign, again, get in touch. If you’re not a WhatCounts customer, consider becoming one today to get access to more great strategies like this one.

Christopher S. Penn
Director of Inbound Marketing, WhatCounts


18 Ways book cover
Audience to Evangelist
Learn 18 different ways to find and grow your email marketing and social media ROI! Promote email with social, social with email, learn how to set up a Facebook Page for email subscriptions, and much more. Download the free eBook now.
Lifecycle email marketing is one of the hottest buzzwords in digital marketing, but how can you make it work for you? Download our free eBook and learn 5 lifecycle frameworks plus practical applications to your email marketing program.

Share this page: